Synthetic vs. Conventional Oil: Which to Choose

Not sure which oil to use for your car? Here's the answer upfront: Synthetic oil offers better performance, longer intervals between changes, and superior engine protection, especially in extreme temperatures or for modern engines. Conventional oil, on the other hand, is cheaper upfront and works well for older vehicles or those with simpler needs.

Quick Overview:

• Synthetic Oil: Engineered for consistent performance, better in hot/cold weather, lasts up to 15,000 miles, costs more upfront.
• Conventional Oil: Made from refined petroleum, breaks down faster, lasts 3,000-5,000 miles, costs less initially.

Bottom Line: Synthetic oil is ideal for most modern cars, turbocharged engines, and extreme climates. Conventional oil is a budget-friendly option for older vehicles or when frequent changes are manageable. Always check your car’s manual for the manufacturer’s recommendation.

‍

Synthetic vs Conventional Oil - There's A Good Reason To Switch

‍

1. Basic Differences: Synthetic vs. Conventional Oil

The main difference between synthetic and conventional motor oils lies in how they are made and their molecular structure. These differences directly affect how well they perform and protect your engine.

How Synthetic Oil is Made

Synthetic oil is crafted with precision. Its molecules are designed to be stable and consistent, and it includes additives like detergents for cleanliness, anti-wear agents for protection, and antioxidants to resist breakdown over time^[1][4].

How Conventional Oil is Made

Conventional oil starts as crude petroleum extracted from the earth. During refining, the crude oil is separated into components based on molecular weight^[1]. The resulting base oil has molecules of different shapes and sizes, which can lead to less reliable performance in extreme temperatures^[3].

These differences in structure are the reason synthetic oils often outperform conventional ones in various tests.

While the composition is essential, the gap in performance becomes even more obvious when oils are tested under stress – something we’ll explore in the next section.

2. Performance Tests and Results

The structural makeup of synthetic and conventional oils leads to noticeable differences when put to the test under extreme conditions.

Hot and Cold Weather Performance

Synthetic oils excel in extreme temperatures. They remain fluid at temperatures as low as -50°C, while conventional oils struggle below -15°C. At -30°C, synthetic oils reach engine components 6 seconds faster, ensuring quicker protection ^[4][5].

When it comes to hot weather, the gap widens further:

Engine Wear and Sludge Tests

In tests simulating city driving, synthetic oils deliver up to 4x better wear protection compared to conventional oils ^[7]. This durability is key for engines under constant stop-and-go conditions.

Sludge testing, such as the Sequence VG Engine Test, highlights another major advantage. Synthetic oils resist sludge buildup far better:

"In a 216-hour test, synthetic oils showed less than 10% of the engine covered in sludge, while conventional oils allowed up to 50-60% sludge coverage" ^[6].

This resistance to sludge is especially important for high-performance engines, like those in turbocharged vehicles. Synthetic oils stay stable at temperatures as high as 400°F ^[8], while conventional oils begin to degrade at 250-300°F.

Moreover, synthetic oils retain their protective qualities for up to 15,000 miles, far outlasting conventional oils, which require replacement every 3,000-5,000 miles ^[7].

3. Price Comparison and Value

Synthetic oils often outperform conventional oils in performance tests, but their higher price tag makes it important to consider overall value. A 5-quart jug of synthetic oil usually costs between $45-$70, compared to $20-$30 for conventional oil ^[4]. Many newer vehicles also require synthetic oil to maintain warranty compliance ^[2][4].

Purchase Price and Change Frequency

The cost of an oil change varies depending on the type of oil used. Here's a quick breakdown:

• Synthetic Oil: Cost per change averaged $65 to $125 while the annual cost ranged from $130 to $250 per year
• Conventional Oil: Cost per change averaged $35 to $75 while the annual cost ranged from $140 to $300 per year

*Based on an average of 15,000 miles driven annually ^[2].

Total Cost Over Time

While synthetic oil has a higher upfront cost, it offers potential savings in other areas. For example, its lower friction properties can improve fuel efficiency by 2-3%, translating to $50-$75 in annual fuel savings at $3 per gallon ^[2].

Synthetic oil is especially cost-effective for:

• Turbocharged engines
• Short, frequent trips
• Heavy towing ^[3][5]

Though the initial expense is higher, synthetic oil's longer intervals between changes and better engine protection can lead to similar - or even lower - annual maintenance costs compared to conventional oil. Plus, it provides added benefits like improved fuel efficiency and enhanced engine durability.

4. Which Oil Fits Your Car?

Picking the right oil for your car depends on your vehicle's design and the conditions you drive in. Modern engines have different needs compared to older ones, and weather can also influence the choice.

Modern and Turbocharged Engines

If your car was made after 2000, chances are it performs best with synthetic oil. This is especially true for engines with turbochargers or superchargers, which run at much higher temperatures ^[1].

Synthetic oil works so well for turbocharged engines because of faster oil circulation for cold temperature starts and prevents carbon buildup with turbo maintenance. Brands like Mercedes-Benz and BMW even require synthetic oil for their vehicles ^[1].

Older Cars and High-Mileage Vehicles

Cars with over 75,000 miles often have different needs. While synthetic oil offers excellent protection, older engines may sometimes do better with conventional or high-mileage oils.

For pre-1990 models, conventional oil is often the better option because:

• It’s gentler on older engine seals, which might not hold up well to synthetic oil ^[2].
• Its thicker viscosity helps compensate for wear in older engines.
• It’s more affordable, making frequent oil changes easier on the wallet.

High-mileage oils, whether synthetic or conventional, are specially formulated with additives to reduce leaks and wear. They also include seal conditioners to help maintain older engines.

Weather and Climate Considerations

The climate where you live plays a big role in choosing the right oil. Synthetic oil is better suited for extreme temperatures, as it maintains its viscosity in conditions ranging from -50°F (-45°C) to scorching heat ^[3].

If you live in an area with extreme weather, synthetic oil can save you the hassle of switching oil types for different seasons. It’s especially useful for drivers in harsh climates, a point we’ll touch on further when discussing oil change intervals.

5. Common Oil Myths: Facts vs. Fiction

When it comes to choosing the right oil, misinformation can lead to confusion. Let’s tackle some of the most common myths and set the record straight:

Oil Leaks When Switching Types

Switching to synthetic oil doesn’t cause leaks in a well-maintained engine. Both synthetic and conventional oils adhere to the same SAE standards ^[1][2]. The confusion likely comes from synthetic oil’s ability to clean sludge buildup, which can expose pre-existing leaks that were previously hidden.

"The Automotive Oil Change Association attributes this myth to 1970s-era synthetic oils, noting modern formulations eliminated the issue ^[2]."

Synthetic Oil in Old Engines

There’s a misconception that synthetic oil isn’t suitable for older engines. In fact, it’s often the opposite. A 2022 Pennzoil study on a 2007 Camry with 150,000 miles showed synthetic oil didn’t increase oil consumption and even improved fuel efficiency by 2%.

Modern synthetic oils include advanced additives that reduce wear and clean deposits, making them an excellent choice for older engines - provided the right formulation is used. This aligns with Section 4’s insights on high-mileage engine protection.

6. Oil Change Schedules

Synthetic Oil Change Timing

Synthetic oil changes typically fall between 5,000 and 15,000 miles, depending on how the vehicle is used. Many modern cars are equipped with oil life monitoring systems that can extend intervals up to 15,000 miles. This ties into Section 3's cost analysis, as fewer oil changes mean lower maintenance expenses.

For turbocharged engines mentioned in Section 4, manufacturers like GM recommend adjusting intervals based on driving conditions:

Oil life monitoring systems track factors like engine temperature, RPM, and driving habits to suggest the best timing for an oil change. However, for vehicles operating under severe conditions (as outlined in Section 4), manufacturers caution against relying solely on these systems.

Conventional Oil Change Timing

Conventional oil requires more frequent changes, typically every 3,000 to 5,000 miles. In harsher conditions, such as stop-and-go traffic or dusty environments, the interval shortens to around 3,000 miles. This aligns with Section 2's insights on how conventional oil breaks down faster under heat.

Examples of severe conditions include:

• Frequent stop-and-go driving in urban areas
• Operating in dusty or sandy environments

For vehicles that are driven infrequently, conventional oil should be replaced at least once a year, even if mileage is low. This helps counteract the effects of degradation from cold starts and limited engine warm-up time ^[3].

Signs that an oil change is overdue - consistent with Section 2's sludge findings - include:

• Oil appearing dark or dirty on the dipstick
• Louder engine operation
• An illuminated oil change warning light
• A noticeable drop in fuel efficiency

Conclusion: Selecting Your Oil Type

When choosing oil, consider your vehicle's specific needs and the conditions in which it operates. As shown in earlier performance tests (Section 2) and cost breakdowns (Section 3), synthetic oil often delivers better long-term value despite its higher upfront cost.

Here are some key considerations:

• Vehicle age: Cars from the 1990s onward typically benefit more from synthetic oil.
• Operating climate: Synthetic oil performs better in extreme hot or cold temperatures.
• Driving habits: Frequent stop-and-go traffic or carrying heavy loads makes synthetic oil a better choice.
• Maintenance routine: Synthetic oil allows for longer intervals between changes, ranging from 7,500 to 15,000 miles.

While synthetic oil may cost more initially, its longer change intervals can help offset the extra expense. For modern vehicles, particularly those with turbocharged or high-performance engines, synthetic oil is often a must to ensure peak performance^[3][6].

Always follow your vehicle manufacturer’s recommendations in the owner’s manual. Pay attention to the suggested viscosity and service schedule to ensure you're using the right oil for your car.

In short, synthetic oil provides better protection and durability for most modern vehicles. That said, conventional oil can still work well for older cars or for drivers who stick to regular oil change intervals.

FAQs

Is synthetic oil better than conventional oil?

Yes, synthetic oil offers superior lubrication and resists oxidation more effectively than conventional oil ^[1][3]. Engine wear tests (see section 2) consistently show synthetic oil outperforming conventional options.

How do I know if my car needs full synthetic oil?

The best way to find out is by checking your owner's manual. For more detailed advice, refer to the vehicle-specific recommendations in section 4.

Synthetic oil is often recommended for:

• Modern vehicles: Turbocharged engines usually require synthetic oil.
• High-performance vehicles: Sports cars and luxury models often need synthetic oil for peak performance.
• Extreme climates: Ideal for driving in temperatures below -20°F or above 90°F.
• Heavy-duty use: Perfect for towing or frequent short trips ^[5].

Is it better to use synthetic oil or regular oil?

Synthetic oil generally provides better engine protection, as highlighted in section 3's cost analysis. Key benefits include:

• Fewer oil changes.
• Longer engine life.
• Reliable performance in extreme temperatures.

Although synthetic oil costs more upfront, its extended intervals between changes and added protection often make it a smarter long-term choice ^[1][4]. That said, conventional oil is still a practical option for older vehicles with simpler engines and consistent maintenance routines.